Patrik,
Sorry… my fault.. Got it Fixed. Figured out what the issue was after you mentioned Shield. It goes back to the issue that we can NOT Export our GD settings after we have a site setup like we want it. So the only way is to use something like the Duplicator plugin.. which is what I used.
then two things happened. I never thought to change the Recaptcha setting on the new website in Shield. I had it set to ignore the Administrator and even with all my testing of the Login and Registration in different browsers I never had seen that issue.
I was getting a number of spammy signups almost daily so it was working. But because of the spammy signups I decided to add Shield’s Anti bot JS protection to my forms. I never had an issue in testing and no one ever notified me of an issue in the short time after I added this antibot js protection… until yesterday.. the day after I updated the UserWP plugins.
Soo…. seems like with you pointing out that the Recaptcha was coming from Shield and then realizing that I still had old Recaptcha code in Shield I figured it out. Seems to be working now.
Thanks for your help.